Dual Engine Failure Likely in AI71 Crash, Not Pilot Error: Experts
Was it pilot error or rare twin engine failure? Experts weigh in on AI171 crash as India seeks answers amidst heartbreak and aviation questions.
As India mourns the 241 lives lost in the tragic crash of Air India AI171 just 32 seconds after takeoff from Ahmedabad, Barkha Dutt hosted a deeply informative conversation with aerospace expert Dr. Aditya A. Paranjape of Monash University to sift facts from speculation.
Broadcasting from a diverted Air India flight herself, Barkha Dutt highlighted how misinformation and blame—particularly on pilot Captain Sumit Sabarwal—are overshadowing the urgent need for clear-headed analysis. Dr. Paranjape, using flight data and crash visuals, ruled out pilot error or stall, pointing instead to a rare and catastrophic dual engine thrust loss as the likely cause.
Paranjape emphasized, “The aircraft was properly configured, had sufficient thrust at takeoff, and showed no signs of stall. The simultaneous loss of thrust on both engines is incredibly rare—but that’s what we are seeing.” He urged caution against speculation and conspiracy theories such as sabotage, stressing the need to await data from black boxes.
Barkha Dutt praised the Air India crew for maintaining professionalism amid tragedy and now war-related airspace diversions. She also reminded viewers of the human toll—stories of lost dreams, grieving families, and the lone miraculous survivor.
Conclusion Bottomline by Barkha Dutt: “It wasn’t human error—it was 32 seconds of horror no one could survive. Captain Sumit didn’t have a choice, only a Mayday to give.”
Quote from Dr. Paranjape: “This is not about one mistake—it’s about a rare event machines and humans couldn't prevent.”